Advertisement

Comparison of Effectiveness of Hand-Carried Ultrasound to Bedside Cardiovascular Physical Examination

      This study compared the accuracy of cardiovascular diagnoses by medical students operating a small hand-carried ultrasound (HCU) device with that of board-certified cardiologists using standard physical examinations. Sixty-one patients (38% women; mean age 70 ± 19 years) with clinically significant cardiac disease had HCU studies performed by 1 of 2 medical students with 18 hours of training in cardiac ultrasound and physical examinations by 1 of 5 cardiologists. Diagnostic accuracy was determined by standard echocardiography. Two-hundred thirty-nine abnormal findings were detected by standard echocardiography. The students correctly identified 75% (180 of 239) of the pathologies, whereas cardiologists found 49% (116 of 239) (p <0.001). The students’ diagnostic specificity of 87% was also greater than cardiologists’ specificity of 76% (p <0.001). For nonvalvular pathologies (115 findings), students’ sensitivity was 61%, compared with 47% for cardiologists (p = 0.040). There were 124 clinically significant valvular lesions (111 regurgitations, 13 stenoses). Students’ and cardiologists’ sensitivities for recognizing lesions that cause a systolic murmur were 93% and 62% (p <0.001), respectively. Students’ sensitivity for diagnosing lesions that produce a diastolic murmur was 75%; cardiologists recognized 16% of these lesions (p <0.001). The diagnostic accuracy of medical students using an HCU device after brief echocardiographic training to detect valvular disease, left ventricular dysfunction, enlargement, and hypertrophy was superior to that of experienced cardiologists performing cardiac physical examinations.
      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      References

        • Wray N.
        • Friedland J.
        Detection and correction of house staff errors in physical diagnosis.
        JAMA. 1983; 249: 1035-1037
        • Kinney E.L.
        Causes of false-negative auscultation of regurgitant lesions.
        J Gen Intern Med. 1988; 3: 429-434
        • Stevenson L.W.
        • Perloff J.K.
        The limited reliability of physical signs for estimating hemodynamics in chronic heart failure.
        JAMA. 1989; 261: 884-888
        • Gadsboll N.
        • Hoilund-Carlsen P.F.
        • Nielsen G.G.
        • Berning J.
        • Bruun N.E.
        • Stage P.
        • Hein E.
        Interobserver agreement and accuracy of bedside estimation of right and left ventricular ejection fraction in acute myocardial infarction.
        Am J Cardiol. 1989; 63: 1301-1307
        • Rahko P.S.
        Prevalence of regurgitant murmurs in patients with valvular regurgitation detected by Doppler echocardiography.
        Ann Intern Med. 1989; 111: 466-472
        • St. Clair E.W.
        • Oddone E.Z.
        • Waugh R.A.
        • Corey G.R.
        • Feussner J.R.
        Assessing housestaff diagnostic skills using a cardiology patient simulator.
        Ann Intern Med. 1992; 117: 751-756
        • Heckerling P.S.
        • Wiener S.L.
        • Wolfkiel C.J.
        • Kushner M.S.
        • Dodin E.M.
        • Jelnin V.
        • Fusman B.
        • Chomka E.V.
        Accuracy and reproducibility of precordial percussion and palpation for detecting increased left ventricular end-diastolic volume and mass. A comparison of physical findings and ultrafast computed tomography of the heart.
        JAMA. 1993; 270: 1943-1948
        • Roldan C.A.
        • Shively B.K.
        • Crawford M.H.
        Value of the cardiovascular physical examination for detecting valvular heart disease in asymptomatic subjects.
        Am J Cardiol. 1996; 77: 1327-1331
        • Mangione S.
        • Nieman L.Z.
        Cardiac auscultatory skills of internal medicine and family practice trainee.
        JAMA. 1997; 278: 717-722
        • Gaskin P.R.
        • Owens S.E.
        • Talner N.S.
        • Sanders S.P.
        • Li J.S.
        Clinical auscultation skills in pediatric residents.
        Pediatrics. 2000; 105: 1184-1187
        • Mangione S.
        • Nieman L.Z.
        • Gracely E.
        • Kay D.
        The teaching and practice of cardiac auscultation during internal medicine and cardiology training.
        Ann Intern Med. 1993; 119: 47-54
        • Spencer K.T.
        • Anderson A.S.
        • Bhargava A.
        • Bales A.C.
        • Sorrentino M.
        • Furlong K.
        • Lang R.M.
        Physician-performed point-of-care echocardiography using a laptop platform compared with physical examination in the cardiovascular patient.
        J Am Coll Cardiol. 2001; 37: 2013-2018
        • Mangione S.
        • Nieman L.Z.
        Cardiac auscultatory skills of internal medicine and family practice trainees.
        JAMA. 1997; 278: 717-722
        • Attenhofer Jost C.H.
        • Turina J.
        • Mayer K.
        • Seifert B.
        • Amann F.W.
        • Buechi M.
        • Facchini M.
        • Rocca H.P.B.
        • Jenni R.
        Echocardiography in the evaluation of systolic murmurs of unknown cause.
        Am J Med. 2000; 108: 614-620
        • Bethel C.S.
        Heart sounds in the aged.
        Am J Cardiol. 1963; 11: 763-767
        • Grayburn P.A.
        • Smith M.D.
        • Handshoe R.
        • Friedman B.J.
        • DeMaria A.N.
        Detection of aortic insufficiency by standard echocardiography, pulsed Doppler echocardiography, and auscultation.
        Ann Intern Med. 1986; 104: 599-605
        • Vourvouri E.C.
        • Poldermans D.
        • De Sutter J.
        • Sozzi F.B.
        • Izzo P.
        • Roelandt J.R.
        Experience with an ultrasound stethoscope.
        J Am Soc Echocardiogr. 2002; 15: 80-85
        • Rugolotto M.
        • Chang C.
        • Hu B.
        • Schnittger I.
        • Liang D.H.
        Clinical use of cardiac ultrasound performed with a hand-carried device in patients admitted for acute cardiac care.
        Am J Cardiol. 2002; 90: 1040-1042
        • Bruce C.J.
        • Montgomery S.C.
        • Bailey K.R.
        • Tajik J.
        • Seward J.B.
        Utility of hand-carried ultrasound devices used by cardiologists with and without significant echocardiographic experience in the cardiology inpatient and outpatient settings.
        Am J Cardiol. 2002; 90: 1273-1275
        • DeCara J.M.
        • Lang R.M.
        • Koch R.
        • Bala R.
        • Penzotti J.
        • Spencer K.T.
        The use of small personal ultrasound devices by internists without formal training in echocardiography.
        Eur J Echocardiogr. 2003; 4: 141-147
        • Rugolotto M.
        • Hu B.S.
        • Liang D.H.
        • Schnittger I.
        Rapid assessment of cardiac anatomy and function with a new hand-carried ultrasound device (OptiGo™).
        Eur J Echocardiogr. 2001; 4: 262-269
        • Vourvouri E.C.
        • Poldermans D.
        • Schinkel A.F.L.
        • Koroleva L.Y.
        • Sozzi F.B.
        • Parharidis G.E.
        • Bax J.J.
        • Roelandt J.R.
        Left ventricular hypertrophy screening using a hand-held ultrasound device.
        Eur Heart J. 2002; 23: 1516-1521
        • Kobal S.L.
        • Tolstrup K.
        • Luo H.
        • Neuman Y.
        • Miyamoto T.
        • Mirocha J.
        • Naqvi T.Z.
        • Siegel R.J.
        Usefulness of a hand-carried cardiac ultrasound device to detect clinically significant valvular regurgitation in hospitalized patients.
        Am J Cardiol. 2004; 93: 1069-1072
        • Goodkin G.M.
        • Spevack D.M.
        • Tunick P.A.
        • Kronzon I.
        How useful is hand-carried bedside echocardiography in critically ill patients?.
        J Am Coll Cardiol. 2001; 37: 2019-2022