Advertisement

The nuclear pacemaker: Is renewed interest warranted?

      This paper is only available as a PDF. To read, Please Download here.

      Abstract

      From 1973 through 1987, 155 radioisotope-powered “nuclear” pacemakers were implanted in 132 patients at the Newark Beth Israel Medical Center. The longevity of the first 15 devices, all of which were fixed-rate (VOO) pacemakers, was significantly better than that of 15 lithium-chemistry demand (VVI) pacemakers used as control devices (p = 0.0002). Of the entire cohort of 155 nuclear pacemakers, 136 were VVI devices and 19 were VOO units. The patients with VOO pacemakers needed reoperations more often than did those with VVI pacemakers, chiefly for mode change (p < 0.001). Power-source failure was observed in only 1 case, but 47 nuclear pacemakers were removed for other reasons, including component malfunction (15 units), mode change (12 units), high pacing thresholds (8 units) and lead or connector problems (5 units). The actuarial survival at 15 years was 99% for power sources and 82% for the entire pacing systems (pulse generators plus leads). The frequency of malignancy was similar to that of the population at large and primary tumor sites were randomly distributed. Deaths most commonly were due to cardiac causes (68%). Thus, nuclear pacemakers are safe and reliable and their greater initial cost appears to be offset by their longevity and the resulting decrease in the frequency of reoperations. It is reasonable to suggest that further use be made of long-lasting nuclear power sources for modern pacemakers and other implantable rhythm-management devices.
      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to American Journal of Cardiology
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Smyth NPD
        • Hernandez T
        • Johnson A
        Clinical experience with radioisotopic powered cardiac pacemakers.
        Henry Ford Hosp Med J. 1974; 22: 113-116
        • Parsonnet V
        • Myers GH
        • Gilbert L
        • Zucker IR
        • Shilling E
        • Manhardt M
        Clinical experience with nuclear pacemakers.
        Surgery. 1975; 78: 776-786
        • Laurens P
        • Piwnica A
        • Reidemeister C
        • Chardack WM
        • Gage AA
        Clinical results of the implantation of an isotopic pacemaker.
        in: Thalen HJTh Cardiac Pacing, Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium. Van Gorcum, Assen, The Netherlands1973: 198-208
        • Huffman FN
        • Norman JC
        Nuclear-fueled cardiac pacemakers.
        Chest. 1974; 65: 667-772
        • Kahn AR
        • Hixson JD
        • Puffer JE
        • Bakken EE
        Three-years' clinical experience with radioisotope powered cardiac pacemakers.
        IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 1973; 20: 326-331
        • Smyth NPD
        • Magbvern GJ
        • Cushing WJ
        • Keshishian JM
        • Kelly LC
        • Dixon M
        Preliminary clinical experience with a new radioisotope-powered cardiac pacemaker.
        J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1976; 71: 262-267
        • Smyth NPD
        • Keshishian JM
        • Garcia JM
        • Kelly LC
        • Proctor D
        Clinical experience with the isotopic cardiac pacemaker.
        Ann Thorac Surg. 1979; 28: 14-21
        • Parsonnet V
        • Myers GH
        • Hursen TF
        • Frommer PL
        • Morrow AG
        The American nuclear powered pacemaker.
        Ann Cardiol Angeiol (Paris). 1971; 20: 405-408
        • Smyth NPD
        • Alferness R
        • Shearon L
        • Rockland RH
        • Keshishian JM
        • Johnson A
        Clinical evaluation of a new pulse generator with narrow pulse width for conservation of battery energy.
        J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1974; 68: 471-478
        • Smyth NPD
        • Millette ML
        The isotopic cardiac pacemaker: a ten year experience.
        PACE. 1984; 7: 82-89
        • Smyth NPD
        • Purdy DL
        • Sager D
        • Keshishian JM
        A new multiprogrammable isotopic powered cardiac pacemaker.
        PACE. 1982; 5: 761-766
        • Bernstein AD
        • Camm AJ
        • Fletcher RD
        • Gold RD
        • Richards AF
        • Smyth NPD
        • Spielman SR
        • Sutton R
        The NASPE/BPEG Generic Pacemaker Code for antibradyarrhythmia and adaptive-rate pacing and antitachyarrhythmia devices.
        PACE. 1987; 10: 794-799
        • Parsonnet V
        Power sources for implantable cardiac pacemakers.
        Chest. 1972; 61: 165-172
        • Parsonnet V
        • Hursen TF
        • Myers GH
        The development of radioisotope power sources for pacemakers in the United States.
        in: Thalen HJTh Cardiac Pacing, Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium. Van Gorcum, Assen, The Netherlands1973: 192-197
        • Alais M
        • Berger R
        • Boucher R
        • Hixson JD
        • Laurens P
        • Piwnica A
        The French nuclear-powered pacemaker program.
        ANS Trans. 1970; 13: 508
        • Morrow AG
        • Levitsky S
        • Frommer PL
        • McIntosh CL
        • Parsonnet V
        • Pierce JE
        • Seipp HW
        Experimental evaluation of a radioisotope powered cardiac pacemaker.
        J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1970; 60: 836-841
      1. Medtronic implantable demand isotopic pulse generator Laurens-Alcatel Model 9000; fourth semi-annual clinical evaluation report to the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission. May, 1975
        • Parsonnet V
        • Gilbert L
        • Zucker IR
        • Werres R
        • Atherley T
        • Manhardt M
        • Cort J
        A decade of nuclear pacing.
        PACE. 1984; 7: 90-95
        • Smyth NPD
        • Magovern GJ
        • Ramirez RG
        • Diaz MH
        • Dixon CM
        • Fecht DC
        • Johnson A
        In vivo study of a new radioisotope-powered cardiac pacer.
        J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1975; 70: 2-8
      2. Final generic environmental statement on routine use of plutonium powered cardiac pacemakers. NUREG-0060. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Material, Safety and Safeguards, July 1976
        • Webster EW
        Radiation Dosimetry and Risk Assessment for the Coratomic Pulsar-N1 Isotopic Pacemaker.
        Report to the FDA. May 1987;
        • Silverberg E
        • Lubera JA
        Cancer statistics, 1988.
        CA. 1988; 38: 14
        • Bilitch M
        • Denes P
        • Goldman BS
        • Maloney JD
        • Harthorne JW
        • Griffin JC
        • Furman S
        • Parsonnet V
        Performance of implantable cardiac rhythm management devices.
        PACE. 1988; 11: 371-380
        • Parsonnet V
        • Bernstein AD
        • Galasso D
        Cardiac pacing practices in the United States in 1985.
        Am J Cardiol. 1988; 62: 71-77